#4 REVENGE!

When Odysseus takes his revenge on the suitors, it is not so much out of justice for they do not deserve to die for they have killed no one, but in a manner of war.  To Odysseus the suitors are invaders that need driven out of his “kingdom” and just like when driving out an army, he wants to ensure he won’t be attacked again.  This means he must kill all the suitors.  He was justified not in that justice was upheld, but that he did what he had to do to protect himself and his kingdom.  Had there been a higher authority for Odysseus to plead his case to, he would not have been justified in his actions.  This is exemplified when the gods get involved and Zeus stops his rampage.  The Acts of Revenge by the individual in our day are not justified, because we have a higher authority that we must respect to carry out justice, which sometimes but not always coincides with revenge.

If Athena had the power to

If Athena had the power to make the parents of the suitors "forget" they were upset, do you think she would have also had the power to make the suitors "forget" they wanted to harm Odysseus and take over his palace?? If so, revenge would not be necessary. The fact that Athena had to come in and make nearly the entire town forget they were upset only proves that Odysseus' revenge did not solve any problems.

Odysseus waging war against

Odysseus waging war against the suitors would have meant that they would have had weapons and been able to escape if they chose to.  Surrender is an intigral part of war.  What Odysseus did was a slaughter.  Even though the suitors did acquire arms through the servants help he trapped them like fish in a barrel and ignored all pleas of guilt and repentance